Who is a Tax Protester?
You’ve probably heard someone complain about taxes, maybe even say they hate paying them. That’s pretty normal. But a tax protester is something different. They don’t just complain; they actively refuse to pay taxes based on their often unconventional beliefs about the tax system.
Think of it like this: most people understand that taxes are part of being a citizen and contribute to society. They might not love it, but they accept it as a necessary part of life. A tax protester, on the other hand, believes there’s something fundamentally wrong or invalid about the whole system, and they refuse to participate in it. They often feel as if they’ve found a “loophole” that invalidates tax law, when in fact they haven’t.
Common Arguments Used by Tax Protesters
It’s important to know what kind of arguments these folks use so you can recognize them. These are not legal or accurate, so don’t be misled. They’re often based on misunderstandings of the law or conspiracy theories. Some of the most common include:
-
“The 16th Amendment was never properly ratified.” The 16th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution is what allows the federal government to collect income taxes. Tax protesters often argue that the amendment was not legally ratified and, therefore, income tax is unconstitutional. This has been repeatedly dismissed by the courts.
-
“Wages are not income.” This argument is just flat-out wrong. They will claim that the compensation they receive for their labor is not legally considered “income” and therefore is not taxable.
-
“I’m not a ‘person’ under the tax law.” Some protesters try to claim they are a “natural person” and not a “citizen” (or legal “person”) subject to the tax laws. The law clearly applies to all U.S. citizens and residents regardless of how they may define themselves.
-
“The IRS has no jurisdiction over me.” Tax protesters may claim they’re not under the jurisdiction of the IRS or that the IRS is not a legitimate government agency. The IRS is a government agency with jurisdiction over anyone subject to U.S. tax laws.
-
“I’m a ‘sovereign citizen’ not subject to U.S. laws.” This is another common argument, linked with conspiracy theories, in which people incorrectly believe they are not subject to the authority of the U.S. government.
-
“Only government employees pay income tax.” Another bizarre and completely false claim. Tax law clearly states that the income tax applies to individuals who receive taxable income.
The Legal Reality
The thing is, none of these arguments hold up in court. The U.S. legal system has repeatedly rejected these claims. Tax laws are established by Congress and upheld by the courts. Tax protesters are not engaging in legal tax avoidance; they are simply defying the law and potentially committing tax evasion.
The IRS takes tax protesters very seriously because their actions undermine the tax system. The IRS will aggressively pursue those who refuse to pay taxes based on these types of arguments.
The Consequences of Being a Tax Protester
Choosing to be a tax protester has real and significant consequences. These include:
-
Penalties and Interest: The IRS will add penalties and interest to unpaid tax bills. These can quickly accumulate, making the amount owed even greater.
-
Liens and Levies: The IRS can place a lien on your property, which means you can’t sell it until you’ve paid your taxes. They can also levy your bank accounts or seize your assets to collect what you owe.
-
Criminal Charges: In serious cases, tax protesters can face criminal charges for tax evasion or related offenses. This can result in fines and even jail time.
-
Reputational Damage: Refusing to pay taxes is a serious matter and can hurt your credit and reputation.
-
Time and Energy: Fighting the IRS over these types of arguments is extremely time-consuming, costly, and rarely results in a victory for the taxpayer.
Why Do People Become Tax Protesters?
People become tax protesters for different reasons. Some may truly believe that they’ve discovered a major flaw in the tax system. Others might be influenced by misinformation or conspiracy theories. Some may simply be looking for a way to avoid paying their taxes, even if they know they’re breaking the law.
It’s also worth noting that sometimes these beliefs are related to anti-government sentiment or more extreme worldviews. Often, they may fall victim to scams or predatory behavior that promise them a way out of paying taxes, but leave them with severe consequences.
How is a Tax Protester Different from Legal Tax Avoidance?
There’s a big difference between a tax protester and someone who is legally avoiding taxes. Tax avoidance involves using legitimate strategies to reduce your tax burden within the confines of the law. This might include taking deductions and credits that you’re entitled to, contributing to retirement accounts, or making strategic investment decisions.
Tax protesters, on the other hand, are trying to reject the tax system altogether, and they are doing so illegally. The key difference is that legal tax avoidance is perfectly within the rules and tax protester arguments are not.
Tips for Avoiding Trouble
The most important thing you can do is to pay your taxes on time and correctly. Don’t be swayed by false promises of tax loopholes or arguments that seem “too good to be true.” If you’re having trouble understanding the tax code or think you might owe too much, consult with a qualified tax professional. They can help you with legal tax-saving strategies, explain complex tax rules, and make sure you are complying with the law.
Common Mistakes and Misconceptions
- Thinking they’re “smarter” than the IRS: Many tax protesters believe they’ve figured out a legal secret that others are missing. They mistakenly assume they have found some error or oversight in the tax code, when, in fact, their arguments are groundless.
- Believing the IRS doesn’t have power: Some protesters believe they can simply ignore the IRS, but the IRS has significant legal power to collect taxes.
- Not understanding the consequences: Tax protesters often don’t fully realize the potential penalties, interest, and even criminal charges they might face.
- Misinterpreting the law: Many protesters base their arguments on legal misinterpretations or incorrect sources of information.
- Believing information they read online: The internet is full of misinformation, and some people are lured into these beliefs by predatory actors who do not have the individual’s best interests at heart.
- Thinking you can simply disavow U.S. citizenship and be free of tax: Simply disavowing your U.S. citizenship or making claims that you’re a “sovereign citizen” will not make you immune to U.S. taxes.
Conclusion
Being a tax protester is a risky and ultimately futile approach. It’s essential to remember that tax laws are established by Congress and upheld by the courts. Trying to avoid taxes through illegal means will result in legal trouble, financial problems, and potentially criminal charges. It is important to be skeptical of any information that seems outlandish, and to consult a qualified tax professional before you take any actions regarding your taxes. If you’re having tax problems, there are legal ways to manage them and get the help you need.